Woot! Thanks Gerbil, I've been looking forward to that! No offense or anything, but before you get into the Game Gear games (Chaos, Triple Trouble), you should probably work on SAdva3 and Sonic Adventure 1 & 2. I'm not trying to tell you how to run the division icon business, I'm just recommending that you add the more-played games first. Also, work on Sonic Battle. I've seen a lot of submissions in that lately. If you're going to do Sonic Heroes, then you should use a Sonic head for Team Sonic, Shadow's head for Team Dark, Amy's for Team Rose, and Espio's for Team Chaotix. I dunno what you'd do for Extra. I really like this division icon project, and I hope it expands to all of the games.
EDIT: I got an idea. For Times on all games, use a small stopwatch sprite. For Rings on all games, use a Ring sprite from Sonic 1. For Scores, use the word "SCORE" icon from Sonic 1.